Partnering Employees to Share-Ownership for Good Governance and Growth
Saturday, November 12, 2011
Article Published in "The Pakistan Accountant" July - September, 2011.
Introduction:
Savvy companies that aspire for the engagement not just of their shareholders but also of a wider circle of encompassing customers, employees, communities, suppliers, business partners and relevant nongovernmental organizations can be competitive in the short-term and more sustainable in the long-term as compared to those which focus exclusively on the financial bottom line. Good business is, by its very nature, socially responsible business. It is argued that if employees have an ownership stake they will be are more committed to the company. This leads to motivation and efforts, hence to productivity and profitability.
The question both for business and government is how to engender such participation and involvement and, specifically, whether this can be brought about through employee shareholding, when such individual shareholdings, taken separately, are insignificant in terms of the overall share capital of the enterprise? Even by pooling the voting rights – although not necessarily the actual ownership – of their shares, an employee shareholder trust could represent a significant voice.
However, some mechanism is needed to translate individual employee shareholding stakes into a collective voice that can deliver results, both in terms of representing the interests of employees and in convincing employees that their shareholding gives them a stake in the enterprise. Such a move could have important beneficial effects for corporate performance and hence economic growth. It could also have significant welfare effects in terms of enriching the experience of working life. Main reasons and issues need to be addressed before considering sharing ownership plans are:
The following are some of the reasons for having a sharing ownership plan:
Link between work and reward: If you are going to ask the most from your employees, they will expect something in return. Increasingly, pay is not enough. A plan that rewards employees with a share of the fruits of their labor draws a direct connection between work and reward.
Culture of ownership: When employees are rewarded based on their contributions to the company's success, they feel like owners. As owners, employees have more incentive to increase the company's profitability. However, this strategy will work only if a culture of understanding the company's challenges and contribute to the solutions has been created over time. Open twoway communication, flat management structure and employee involvement foster such a culture faster.
Following are the issues to be considered when creating a sharing ownership plan:
Empower employees to succeed: Employees must be able to make decisions that will have an impact on their bonus. "It [profit sharing] is not worth much, unless there's participation in decision making," says Bob Nelson, president of Nelson Motivation Inc. in San Diego, Calif., and author of 1001 Ways to Reward Employees.
Clear objectives: Before developing a partnership plan, any organization needs to have defined objectives in place; is it employee recruitment? Retention? Do you want liquidity for your equity? Do you want to boost production, or perhaps, you want a little of everything. The answers will help you choose the right plan for your company.
Know your industry: Old economy businesses may have actual profits to share. New economy enterprises may be years from that, so stock options carry more appeal. If your workforce is young and well educated, immediate stock awards provide more motivation. Older workers may be more interested in plans geared toward retirement.
Stage of business development: At the startup stage, a company may want to protect cash and offer stock options. At a rapid-growth or mature stage, when a company has become profitable, stock-option awards, cash and stock bonuses, or profit sharing become possible.
Employee participation within the workplace is generally regarded as important in generating and sustaining loyalty and commitment to the organization. Establishing and sharing a company ethos and culture is seen as a desirable outcome for organizational success. One reason for this is that attempting to secure effort from employees via supervision is at best costly and often difficult if not impossible. Incentive schemes may be impracticable where results depend on team effort. To work, incentives in this case need to go beyond simply appealing to individual calculations of the costs and benefits to the employee of deploying greater effort – since such a calculation would often result in the employee deciding rationally to “free ride” and still benefiting from the collective incentive scheme. Instead, such schemes need to be designed to engender collective trust and commitment.
Shared ownership by employees has long been the subject of corporate and public policy discussions. Given the advantages, meaningful employee participation through the particular route of ownership stakes has taken a number of forms over time and in different economies. Is participation actually enhanced by ownership? Do employee participation and employee share ownership have the same results? To be successful over the long term, companies need to innovate both in what they produce or offer and in the way in which they produce or the processes they adopt. The active participation of the workforce is seen as increasingly important in these processes, particularly in high value added sectors and in the “new economy.” On the other hand, the short-term interests of shareholders may get dividend rather than research and development and other innovative investments; the payback from which may not only be uncertain but also, at best, long term.
Cost cutting strategies and work intensification can bolster profitability in the short term, in the longer term developing participatory and representative mechanisms may prove increasingly important. While it is widely recognized that “flexible” employees are important for firms’ competitiveness, the above work found that such practices need to be complemented with adequate involvement mechanisms including reward systems and training, without which they could result simply in an increased intensification of work.
EMPLOYEE SHARE OWNERSHIP
From individual point of view, it makes more sense to hold shares in a company other than the one for which you work, otherwise, should that company go bankrupt, the individual risks losing his or her savings as well as their job. To advocate the holding of shares in the company for which the individuals actually work therefore requires two things. First, there needs to be a good reason for advocating such a decision. That is, one must be convinced that mechanisms exist to ensure that the sort of potential benefits associated with such ownership.
There must be a visible outcome in terms of company performance that follows as a result of such shareholdings. Otherwise, the employees would be better off holding shares in other different companies. Second, if the mechanisms are in place to ensure that there is a potential benefit then employees should be encouraged to take and hold on such ownership stakes, rather than taking stakes in enterprises other than the one for which they work.
POLICY IMPLICATIONS
Employee shareholder trusts could be used to solve the problem of the owners of listed companies (shareholders) who normally have no interest in the long-term success or otherwise of the firm. As far as the company is concerned, institutional shareholders come and go. An employee shareholder trust would be there for the long haul. They really would have an interest in the good governance and long-term success of the firm. The policy implications of the above discussion are twofold.
First, the tax incentives for employee shareholders could be further developed with the specific aim of encouraging employee shareholders to actively participate in trusts that provide a collective voice within the organization. Such a voice could have a positive impact on the performance of companies and thereby the economy as a whole. Without a belief that such individual collective shareholdings are contributing in a meaningful way towards a collective voice, there may not be the necessary commitment from the individual employee shareholders to hold on to those shares.
Indeed, they might in this case be better advised to sell and re-invest in some different sectors of the economy. There could be ways in which the specifics of how the tax incentives currently operate might be improved. More importantly, the reference to “approved” collective shareholdings is important. The current criteria for approving trusts could be extended so that schemes would be designed and operated in a manner that was clearly open and democratic, and whose objectives were to operate in the best interests of the company, rather than just to maximize financial returns to the individual shareholder.
Second, such schemes are only likely to develop and operate successfully if a body is established to ensure that this happens, along the lines of the existing supporter’s direct unit. The remit of such an organization would go beyond what is currently offered by the Treasury and Inland Revenue. It would allow the appropriate legal and other structures to be developed and to be then provided to any such collective employee-shareholding group. But it would also actively seek to enable each group to benefit from the experience of others in using such holdings to provide an effective collective voice at work.
EMPLOYEE SHARE SCHEME IN PAKISTAN
Section 14 Of Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 has a set of rules that an owner must obey to avoid paying hefty taxes on his or her contracts. In this section “Employee Share Scheme” means any agreement or arrangement under which a company may issue shares in the company to:
(a) An employee of the company or an employee of an associated company; or
(b) The trustee of a trust and under the trust deed the trustee may transfer the shares to an employee of the company or an employee of an associated company.
Provision of this section would apply in Employee Share Scheme as follows:
The grant is not a taxable event: The value of a right or option to acquire shares under an employee share scheme granted to an employee shall not be chargeable to tax. However, consideration received against disposal of right or option would be taxable under the head “Salary” in the year in which disposal will take place.
Taxation begins at the time of exercise: Where, in a tax year, an employee is issued with shares under an employee share scheme including as a result of the exercise of an option or right to acquire the shares, the amount chargeable to tax to the employee under the head “Salary” for that year shall include the fair market value of the shares determined at the date of issue, as reduced by any consideration given by the employee for the shares including any amount given as consideration for the grant of a right or option to acquire the shares.
For example, if an employee is granted 100 shares of Stock A at an exercise price of Rs.25, the market value of the stock at the time of exercise is Rs.50. The amount included in the salary income on the contract is Rs.2,500 (Rs.50 – Rs.25 x 100).
The sale of the security triggers another taxable event: If the employee decides to sell the shares
immediately (or less than a year from exercise), the transaction will be reported as a Capital gain (or loss) and will be subject to tax at ordinary income tax rates and vary from different holding patterns. If the employee decides to sell the shares a year after the exercise, the sale will also be reported as a capital gain (or loss) and the tax will be reduced to a maximum level or would be exempt from tax subject to certain conditions.
CONCLUSION
The philosophy to partnering employees in the business is that if the employees feel that they have a stake in the enterprise or organization in which they work, they will be more committed to work. This in turn will bring positive outcomes in terms of productivity and organizational performance. This is time-tested theory and is based upon simple logic which
every sane manager acknowledges. Partnering employees creates significant links between progressive human resource practices that promote participation and involvement, corporate performance and organizational outcomes on the one hand and getting taxation benefit of holding such participation by the employees on the other.
_____________________
About the authors:
Athar Hussain is a senior finance professional in Iran, a fellow member of the Institute, on the visiting faculty of various institutions - professional bodies and universities, lecturing in various management disciplines.
Mubeshir Ali Kazmi, M.Com, ACA is a CFO and Company Secretary in Pakistan and on the teaching faculty of a number of institutions.
The readers are welcome to contact the authors to discuss any part of this article on email:
Athar Hussain: atharhzaidi@hotmail.com,
Mubeshir Ali: mobiali@gmail.com
Labels: Ather Zaidi, Employers Share Scheme, Governance, Mubeshir Ali, The Pakistan Accountant
posted @ 12:32 PM,
,
Energy and Capital
Friday, November 11, 2011
One of my friends is very keen to get such sort of resources which would be beneficial for him to get the foresight and vision to exploit the commercial opportunities of a post-oil economy through daily published commentary, research, and investment ideas centered around the end of the oil age and the technologies. This will certainly help him make a smooth transition among different type of energy resources.
Energy is such an important resource that it affects every single human venture due to its cheapness and convenient availability. Each and every one of us uses more energy than the previous generation. From wood to whale oil to coal to oil, every transition has given them access to cheaper energy and created vast amounts of new wealth. Energy crisis is beginning to make its way into the media limelight, but very few people are aware of its true scope and magnitude. And there is a great opportunity will rise from the ashes of this crisis like Natural gas investments.
Visit the neatly laid out site of Energy and Capital which are providing free, daily newsletter offering investment advice and analysis for the energy market. Each issue is written by one of our renowned experts in the field, whose work has been recognized everywhere from the Wall Street Journal to CNBC. The reporting and ideas they’ll give you are consistently at least one fiscal quarter ahead of the mainstream media. Periodically you will also receive promotions that offer opportunities to expand your investment knowledge even further. While the Energy and Capital website offers access to the articles and reports, as a newsletter subscriber you will be among the first to receive access to the valuable advice, delivered directly to your inbox daily, and you will have access to deals on our exclusive services.
posted @ 5:09 PM,
,
UK Cleaning Products
Tuesday, November 1, 2011
Enter any living space, home or an office, hotel or airport lounge, and the standard of cleanliness will form your first idea of a place. Cleaner the place, better the image you form. If the things are messed up, given chance, you would not like to deal with the place again in anyway. That is why one people going a long way to clean up. More so in corporate world.
The cleaning of living spaces – interior and exterior – is a fine art as well as science. The living spaces cleaning activities includes the cleaning of edifice’s facades and floors, the cleaning of steel structures such as bridges, wind turbines, and the cleaning of tunnels, sewage systems as well as items placed inside the space.
In modern living spaces, such as office blocks, supper stores, hotels or a hospital, facades and partitions made of glass are widely used. To maintain the characteristics and transparency of these building elements over the long term, they have to be regularly cleaned. How these requirements can be met cost-efficiently and with the necessary thoroughness.
One needs to have a right product for a right job. May be your cleaning staff doesn’t know the difference between cotton cleaning material and micro fiber cleaning products. Which one absorbs water more and which one lasts longer? I suggest the mangers at the upper ladder of the pyramid need to decide before bulk purchase. That is how any concern can save on cleaning products. No?
Labels: Cleaning products
posted @ 6:41 PM,
,
Money Market, Forex & General Updates - 31-10-2011
Money Market Updates
Money market opened at 11.50 with high of 11.85 and a low of 11.40. Market closed at 11.85 percent.
Forex Market Updates
Dollar market inter bank opened at 86.65/67 with a high of 86.65 and a low of 86.48. Market closed at 86.50/52.
General Updates
The much-awaited Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation number for the month of October is expected to be released this week, which is likely to fall in the range of 10-10.3 percent as against 10.5 percent for September, analysts said. This would be the third consecutive monthly decline which will render four months' FY12 average inflation to 11.2 percent as compared to 13.9 percent in the same period of last year.
The Sensitive Price Indicator (SPI), for the week ended on October 27 for the lowest income group up to Rs.8,000, has registered increase of 0.55 percent over the previous week. The SPI for the week under review in the above mentioned group was recorded at 171.36 points against 170.42 points registered in the previous week, according provisional figures of Federal Bureau of Statistics (FBS). The weekly SPI has been computed with base 2007-2008=100, covering 17 urban centers and 53 essential items for all income groups and combined. SPI for the combined group registered increase of 0.44 percent as it went up from 176.59 points in the previous week to 177.37 points in the week under review.
The exports of various sports goods increased by 5.39 percent during the first quarter of the current fiscal year as against the same period of last year. The overall sports goods' exports during July-September (2011- 12) stood at $79.469 million against the exports of $75.407 million during July - September (2010-11), Federal Bureau of Statistics reported. Among the sports products, the exports of footballs surged by 16.38 percent by increasing from $31.931 million in July-September (2010-11) to $37.161 million during the same period of current fiscal year.
Labels: Economy and Business, Money Market, Pakistan Economy
posted @ 10:31 AM,
,
Small Business Loans
After the advent of internet, people and most of the companies have started their business through online regarding providing of small business loans and personal loans. To obtain a reasonable solution for getting Small Business Loans or a Personal loan for the average person, it is always a confusing and daunting job. Further, there are number of concerns which are available in the market providing such services and claiming they are the best among all.
However, we need such expert loan consultants those will guide us through the entire process from the initial application to walking away with our financial goals at competitive rate. I personally found Unsecured Solutions one of the best among all where you can apply for New Business Loans and Personal Loans. They always make sure that they will take all the proper steps to make the loan process easy, and fast. They offer all types of unsecured loans that will fit into what you are trying to accomplish.
Visit the neatly laid out site and see how they are offering about small business loans and Personal Loan ranging from $10k to $250k for good and excellent credit applicants.
posted @ 10:08 AM,
,
